Darfur

Hey George Clooney, I hope you and your well-meaning but rather sadly incompetent liberal friends at Save Darfur  and Enough Project are happy.

Great, the arrest warrant has been issued, now what? Huh, now what?

What about you Nicholas Kristof?

Listen guys, I appreciate your well-meaning sentiments. I really do. We all pretty much agree on the goals: a peaceful, stable, and democratic Sudan.

Where we sharply part ways is on the means, and to put it bluntly, I think yours are utter shit.

(New York) - The Sudanese government’s announcement that it will expel 10 international aid agencies places the lives of more than 1 million people in Darfur at risk, Human Rights Watch said today.

What’s your plan now Clooney and Co.?

Sit back and wait for the super reliable UN and so-called international community to pursue… yeah, what’s that thing called again, wait, let me remember, oh yeah “aggressive diplomacy”…

… to change  the evil hideous ways of our deeply “beloved” Omar Hassan al-Bashir, aka the “protector” of Sudan and Islam waging a jihad of pure awesomeness against the Evil Western Zionist Piggy Ape CrUSAders, right?

Seriously, what’s your plan?

Lobby, what’s his name again, yeah, President Barack Hussein Obama to do something, anything right? Pursue “aggressive diplomacy” too right?

Right.

As if the economy is in such wonderful shape and American tax payers are in the mood for another US-led military adventure abroad.

Ladies and gentlemen, I wish my predictions were wrong, but it is precisely because of the above quoted text that I’ve been reluctant to support the ICC warrant as explained in this previous post of mine.

For the millionth time, the pursuit of justice is highly important but not at the great risk of endangering the very people facing the injustice in the first place.

Alex De Waal, a true Sudan-expert and scholar who’s actually lived in Darfur and written numerous books on Sudan agrees (HRW’s Richard Dicker and Scholar, Mediator Alex de Waal Debate ICC Indictment of Sudanese President for Mass Killings in Darfur).

Julie Flint agrees too. She’s another real Sudan-expert, unlike the other experts or so-called Sudan experts who are dangerously out of touch.

Here’s to hoping the humanitarian situation doesn’t worsen into a disaster.

Thanks to the lovely Sudanese Optimist, I found this AlertNet link which features a number of Sudanese bloggers. I was also just kindly notified by Global Voices Online that CNN’s Inside Africa covered their roundups of the Sudanese blogosphere.

Awesome.

Keep’em coming fellow Sudanese bloggers. Heck, tell your Sudanese friends to start blogging too. We could certainly use a litte more activity around here.

Here are the thoughts of Sudanese bloggers so far in reaction to the ICC’s arrest warrant for our lovely dictator. First, let’s check what Nesrine at Cif thinks of this:

Toothless and badly-timed as the indictment of Sudan’s president may be, morally we cannot afford not to support it.

… The timing was unfortunate. Many in the Arab world are still reeling from the recent incursion into Gaza and governments are continuing to capitalise on anti-western sentiment. The ostensible hypocrisy of targeting Bashir when apparently Israel and the west are impune renders his martyrdom on the altar of international double standards convenient for Arab or African heads of state living in their own glass houses.

[click to continue...]

This is an open thread to discuss the upcoming ICC decision on the arrest warrant for dictator Omar Hassan al-Bashir. It’s expected to be announced in a matter of hours.

Here’s my analysis. Here’s the in-depth one by Enough Project. It’s awesome, but they’re placing too much hope on the international community and the UN I think.

Dear fellow Sudanese bloggers, drop a link to your own blog post on the matter in the comments section so that it will get noticed by the media. I’ve got a number of journalists emailing me, and they’re all interested in hearing what we Sudanese bloggers have to say about this.

Everyone else, share your thoughts, if any. This is potentially history in the making. Meanwhile, I’m gonna go find me some pop-corn.

Let the “entertainment” begin!

UPDATE: Ooo, surprise of the century! So what’s gonna happen now? Will Bashir get overthrown by Salah Gosh or something? Dum dum dum… the plot thickens! Oh yeah. More pop-corn please.

UPDATE: This is bad news, and I’m not surprised at all by it. Here’s the latest from Rob Crilly’s Twitter stream:

10 NGOs being kicked out of Sudan altogether. Include Oxfam, Care, ACF. Got calls seconds after ICC presser started

hearing it may be 13 NGOs, probably cannot confirm at this time of night

Getting increasingly irritated by celebrations for the ICC. People should check out what’s happening here, not listen to Save Darfur

NGOs appealing. Will Khartoum have the balls to see it through? Masters of reversing decisions, centre overruling regional authorities etc

laptops and phones being taken from charities here now

More here.

It’s been seven months since news broke out about the ICC’s pursuit of an arrest warrant for Sudanese dictator Omar al-Bashir, charging him with genocide and war crimes against humanity, a move that brought about entertaining Sudanese reactions.

Seven months, and it seems to me that there are some who can hardly wait for the issuance of this arrest warrant as if it’s some kind of magical solution that’s going to bring peace and stability to Darfur.

[click to continue...]

I’ve had my issues with the Save Darfur Coalition previously, but this looks like a good initiative. If you’re American, get on board and sign. It only takes less than a minute. And it’s the least we could do.

It’s a conspiracy to try and seem fair, don’t be fooled.

This week the ICC prosecutor submitted a sealed application to the judges requesting an arrest warrant be issued against three Darfur rebel leaders whose names were not disclosed.

The counts against the rebel leaders included war crimes of violence to life, intentionally directing attacks against personnel, installations, material, units or vehicles involved in a peacekeeping mission and pillaging.

The U.S. special envoy to Sudan, Richard Williamson in an interview with Reuters welcomed the ICC move against rebel groups.

“I believe that for justice to be credible and for restorative justice to take place, all sides who commit crimes against humanity, war crimes, genocide have to be held to account” the US official said.

Conspiracy, I tell you!

By far one of the best articles on Sudan I’ve come across in recent weeks. Great analysis.

… in the past few weeks three newish factors have coalesced to create a set of circumstances that could shake the country up: for better, if matters are handled carefully, or for much worse. The first is the prospect of national elections next year; the second is the beginning of proceedings against President Omar al-Bashir by the International Criminal Court (ICC) on charges of genocide over Darfur; and the third is the election of Barack Obama as the next president of the United States. Each of these factors, on its own, would not bother Mr Bashir much. But the three together are now putting considerable pressure on him to change course in Darfur and get serious about peace with the south.

Keep reading it here.

(hat-tip: Nobody)

… I mean the Muslim and Arab hypocrisy in regards to the Darfur conflict. He succinctly says what I’ve been hammering across here for ages together with some active commenters.

~*~

Muslim minority: Hey, there are Muslims getting killed in Darfur.

Muslim majority: Really? By the evil Joooz?

Muslim minority: No, by other Muslims.

Muslim majority: …

In the grand scheme of things, China’s indirect involvement in the Darfur conflict deserves all the scrutiny it can get, but in the microcosm, this is completely uncalled for and unacceptable.

Sudan denied yesterday that they were killed during a rescue operation but Beijing said they were killed after clashes with Sudanese troops. Khartoum insists the kidnappers panicked when a helicopter hovered overhead.

Also, Sudan accused the Justice and Equality Movement of abduction and the killing, while the rebels dismissed the accusations saying Misseriya people were behind the murder.

It’s still unclear who is responsible for the murders, but I don’t see any motivations the government can have for doing this.

Dear Darfur rebels,

I hope I’m wrong but if you were behind this, then way to go. First it was your attack on Khartoum, and now, it’s this. You do realize, there are better ways to get your point across right? Clearly, this isn’t one of them. It only does more harm than good to your supremely legitimate cause.

My condolences go out to the families of the workers.

Oh well, at least they’ve managed to flee from all the killing and bloodshed.

May they find peace and stability in their new home, and may the filthy butchers who drove them away and slaughtered their people face the fates they deserve.

Rob Crilly is not one anymore and boy am I glad.

My lurch from left-wing idealist living in Britain, to right-wing realist in Africa continues apace. This time it is The Spectator that seems to have nailed the analysis of Darfur…

The exclusive focus on bashing the government has emboldened the rebels, encouraging them to keep up the fight and shun the negotiating table. The peace process, as a result, has collapsed. Though uncontroversial among seasoned Sudan watchers, such a view is politically incorrect in the West, where the debate has been held in the shadows of a glossy campaign long on sentiment and outrage, short on measured analysis.

Rob is one of the few people in this part of the blogosphere neighborhood who has a pretty solid understanding of what’s going on in Darfur and Sudan. Be sure to check his blog every now and then.

~*~*~*~

Even now, after all this time, I still get pretty annoyed by how the debate on Darfur in the West is still mostly based on a simplistic narrative of good Vs bad. Not just that, but the opinions of real experts, heavy weight Sudanese analysts and knowledgeable opposition party members, are not taken into sufficient consideration.

Less feel-good activism, more dispassionate analysis please.

Yes, take that, in your face you Evil Zionists! What am I talking about you ask? Here’s what.

Darfur native, Ismail Ahmed Ismail won Sudan a silver medal during the recent lovely Olympic games held in the human rights respecting nation of China. Meanwhile, Israel only won one bronze medal.

Ahaha, losers! We win!

Okay, so that’s the first smack. The second smack is a little more complicated.

Having a Darfur native participate in the Olympic games held in “genocide-supporting” China weakens the notion that Darfur is witnessing mass atrocities, which is nothing but a dirty lie being circulated by the Evil Zionist CrUSAders.

Bam! Second smack!

On a more serious note though, I’d like to congratulate Ismail on this achievement. He surely had to endure a lot.

Ismail’s family is from western Darfur, but like many others, they migrated from the impoverished region to Khartoum before he was born.

… Ismail’s family couldn’t be immediately reached for comment. But the 23-year-old runner has not had it easy.

Hanadi Ismail, a reporter and family friend, said he and his five brothers and sisters grew up in the poor Khartoum neighborhood of Hajj Youssef.

Ismail’s wife gave birth to their son just 42 days ago, but has yet to name him because they cannot afford the naming ceremony.

Can’t afford the naming ceremony? WTF?

Dear beloved Sudanese government, for once, stop being so damn corrupted and give the poor guy a well-deserved award for heaven’s sake.

Yeah, surprise, surprise. Oooo, how shocking.

Well, no, not really. It’s a very expected stance. Sudan is siding with Russia over this crisis, but that’s not the hilarious part. The hilarious part which made me laugh really hard is the one I put in bold.

August 15, 2008 (KHARTOUM) –The Sudanese National Assembly lent its support Moscow in its clash with Georgia over the border region of South Ossetia.

The Sudanese legislative body described the Russian response as “legitimate” and that Moscow had “the right to defend its citizens”.

Sudan also condemned the “crimes committed by Georgian forces against innocent citizens”.

“The genocide was committed in its worst forms and did not spare even the elders or children or sick or women” the foreign relations committee said in a statement.

Sudan and Russia enjoy good relations particularly in terms of military cooperation. Moscow along with Beijing blocked tough UN Security Council (UNSC) measures against Khartoum over the Darfur conflict.

Boy, oh boy, the pot calling the kettle black. This is such priceless entertainment.

I love it!